Criticized law brings about fairness - S. Florida Business & Wealth

Criticized law brings about fairness

[vc_row css_animation=”” row_type=”row” use_row_as_full_screen_section=”no” type=”full_width” angled_section=”no” text_align=”left” background_image_as_pattern=”without_pattern”][vc_column width=”2/3″][vc_column_text]

Development is an expensive, time-consuming business. Getting a project from concept to approval can cost tens of thousands of dollars—and often more—before a shovel even goes into the ground. It can take six months to several years for a new project to work its way through the layers of zoning, site planning, public hearings, and city and county governmental approvals.

Then, once a developer has run the governmental and public hearing gantlet to get all required approvals, a lawsuit from an activist organization or community group opposing a development can tie up a project for more years to come.

Gov. Ron DeSantis recently signed Florida’s 2019 Community Planning and Growth Management bill. It creates a “prevailing party” provision. The winning party to a lawsuit challenging a development, based on its consistency with a jurisdiction’s comprehensive plan, is entitled to recover reasonable attorney fees. 

The multipronged legislation (House Bill 7103) was signed by the governor against a backdrop of controversy and negative headlines.

“Goal of Republicans in Tallahassee: Make the people of Florida voiceless and powerless,” said a July 19 Sun-Sentinel editorial. Its contention was that just the mere risk of losing robs the public’s ability to counter a governing authority’s action.

But the other side of this coin is that the bill also enables citizen or community groups that have solid legal arguments against a development to win with their legal fees covered, thus creating an additional financial stick to hold governmental agencies more accountable in prudent review of all development. Developers also get snagged when a project is denied because of public and political pressure even though it may meet all permitted uses. They, too, could prevail and recover their legal costs.

“I believe the prevailing party provision is a great addition and will not lessen the voice of the people, but reduce the amount of frivolous challenges that are filed to stall developments,” says Heidi Davis Knapik, a land use and development lawyer at the Gunster law firm. “This provision will require that all parties have sound legal arguments prior to filing a challenge in circuit court, which costs thousands of dollars and could take years to resolve. Parties will think hard the next time they may not like a development that meets all the criteria, and instead of being quick to file a lawsuit that they may not be able to win, they should work together with the developer or the city to resolve the issues.”  

Right now, she says, the legal challenge process is onerous, circular and can stall projects to the point of bankrupting them.

In addition to the prevailing party provision, the legislation also seeks to address other thorny issues.

Perhaps one of the costlier ones for developers has been local governments’ ability to mandate inclusionary zoning for affordable housing or require that developers pay into housing funds. The bill requires that the cost to developers of such affordable housing mandates be fully offset through density bonuses and other incentives.

“A chief complaint around the state is the push for affordable housing on the backs of commercial developers,” says Chris Carmody, a regulatory, government affairs and land use lawyer at the Gray Robinson firm. “This legislation makes clear that if a local government prioritizes affordable housing in developments, it must fully offset the costs associated with it.”

This surely is welcomed by local developers as Broward County once again mulls levying an affordable housing linkage fee on commercial development.

Davis Knapik says another key provision of the bill is expedited review times by counties and municipalities for development permits and development orders. The timeline for agencies to approve, approve with conditions or deny the application is 120 days from the application’s completion for nonquasi-judicial proceedings or 180 days for quasi-judicial proceedings.

“Time is money, and stalled or delayed applications cost the development community a tremendous amount of money,” Davis Knapik says. “This pushes the agencies along and sets forth time frames.” ↵

Freelance writer Darcie Lunsford is a former real estate editor of the South Florida Business Journal. She is the senior VP for leasing at Butters Group and is avoiding a conflict of interest in her column by not covering her own deals.

[/vc_column_text][/vc_column][vc_column width=”1/3″][vc_gallery interval=”3″ images=”34299,34300″ img_size=”full”][/vc_column][/vc_row]

You May Also Like
Building Ave Maria 

For Blake Gable, the story of Ave Maria has never been about reaching a set finish line.  Twenty-four years after Barron Collier Companies began work on the Southwest Florida community,

Read More
People sit in golf carts parked near a restaurant with outdoor seating under umbrellas on a sunny day in a lively, colorful urban area with trees and surrounding buildings. South Florida Business & Wealth
Miami’s Rider Residences Tops Off Construction

Ciprés, the next-generation real estate development firm, in partnership with veteran South Florida developer Rilea Group, announced the recent topping off of construction for The Rider Residences, rising 12 stories at 94

Read More
A rooftop restaurant with a green roof, palm trees, and people dining at tables. The floor has a checkered pattern, and the space is stylishly decorated with plants and modern furniture. South Florida Business & Wealth
Driftwood Capital Unifies Credit and Equity Under Co-CIO Leadership

 Driftwood Capital (“Driftwood”), a vertically integrated hospitality real estate investment firm, today named David Resnick Partner and co-Chief Investment Officer and elevated David Steiner, co-founder of the firm’s credit platform, to

Read More
Three men in business suits pose against a plain gray background, each facing the camera in individual portrait frames, all wearing white shirts and dark jackets, with neutral to slight smiles. South Florida Business & Wealth
Discovery Land Company Appoints Alicia Goldstein President, Eastern United States

Discovery Land Company (“Discovery”), the developer and operator of private residential club communities announced the appointment of Alicia Goldstein as president, Eastern United States. In this newly created role, Goldstein

Read More
Woman with long dark hair and light skin smiles at the camera, wearing a white top, with a plain white background behind her. South Florida Business & Wealth
Other Posts
Gencom Announces Leadership Appointments

Miami-based real estate investment firm Gencom is reorganizing its operations and expanding its leadership team as it prepares for its next stage of global growth. The company announced it has

Read More
A man in a black t-shirt stands indoors, smiling at the camera. The background features warm lighting, framed art on the wall, and blurred furnishings in a spacious room. South Florida Business & Wealth
Douglas Elliman is the Exclusive Sales Firm for Greenview at Presidential

Greenview at Presidential, a new gated community of 103 luxury single-family homes near Aventura, has tapped Douglas Elliman Development Marketing to handle sales as the project begins welcoming residents. Developed

Read More
Luxurious outdoor swimming pool area at dusk with lounge chairs, umbrellas, palm trees, lanterns, and a modern building in the background. The pool reflects the evening sky, creating a serene atmosphere. South Florida Business & Wealth
Calaveras Cantina to Open at Mayla Pompano

 Grover Corlew today announced that Calaveras Cantina, the popular South Florida restaurant concept known for its elevated Mexican cuisine, craft cocktails and lively atmosphere, will open a new location at the company’s

Read More
A modern building at sunset features "Calaveras Cantina" in red neon letters, surrounded by greenery, palm trees, and outdoor lights along a landscaped pathway. South Florida Business & Wealth
Basis Industrial Names Anthony Scavo CEO, Nisha Patel COO

 Basis Industrial, a vertically integrated real estate owner and operator, today announced the expansion of its executive leadership team with Anthony Scavo assuming the role of CEO and managing partner,

Read More
A man wearing a dark blue suit and white shirt poses against a plain white background, looking directly at the camera with a neutral expression. South Florida Business & Wealth