New Yorkers and Californians Pricing Locals Out of Real Estate Market

Veteran South Florida real estate agent Susan Rindley says the influx of people to South Florida from California, New York and New Jersey is why locals are having a hard time buying a home in the current real estate market. 

“Locals are being priced out,” Rindley says. “If you think about the real estate markets in New York and California, the prices here in South Florida are still considered cheap for those buyers. Not only can they offer more in a bidding war, they are coming with cash, so their offers are much more attractive to sellers.” 

Rindley says all of her recent sales have broken records. She sold a condo in Sunny Isles for $6.65 million at $2,050 per square foot. That’s unheard of in South Florida, where the average condo sells for under $500 per square foot. She also recently sold a house off Las Olas Blvd. in Fort Lauderdale for $14,500,000 and a house in Sunrise Key for $7 million at $1,775 per square foot. The average list price of a home in South Florida is about $300 per square foot. 

“My out-of-town buyers are from high-tax urban areas like New York, New Jersey, California and Chicago where they are used to paying $2,000 to $5,000 per square foot for a home. They all love South Florida, not only for the weather and tax breaks but are now moving here in droves because of fewer COVID restrictions,“ Rindley says. 

In May alone, Rindley closed $40 million in sales. The market is still strong, but interest from out-of-town buyers has slowed down in recent weeks in South Florida because people are traveling to places like Europe, the Hamptons and Aspen for the summer. Rindley says they will be back by October looking for waterfront homes and yachts. Fort Lauderdale is the yachting capital of the world and the popular Fort Lauderdale International Boat Show is in October again this year. 

“My advice is if you’re local and looking to buy in the luxury market, do it now, “ Rindley says. 

Susan Rindley is a luxury real estate agent with ONE Sotheby’s International Realty. Susan specializes in waterfront estates and luxury condominiums in Palm Beach, Boca Raton, Fort Lauderdale Beach and South Beach Miami neighborhoods. Susan grew up in South Florida and has lived in Palm Beach, Fort Lauderdale and Miami, so her knowledge of the South Florida market is unparalleled. To learn more, visit www.susanrindley.com.

You May Also Like
Florida and Texas Are Gaining Residents at a Slower Rate, Redfin Reports

The rising cost of housing and the increasing frequency of natural disasters are slowing migration to Florida and Texas metros.

Read More
Live Local Act Could Finally Make an Impact on Housing

These proposed updates could finally fulfill the Act’s original promise – bringing critically needed housing to high-cost areas.

Read More
Luxury Development Glass House Boca Raton Breaks Ground

The nine-story residential development is slated for completion in Q2 2027. 

Read More
14 Florida Insurers Closed Over Half of Homeowner Damage Claims with Zero Payment in 2024

Weiss Ratings warns of worsening trends in Florida’s insurance industry, noting a sharp rise in homeowner claims closed without payment.

Read More
Other Posts
The Housing Search is Easing, but a Prolonged Trade War Could Derail Progress

Buyer difficulty is easing, owing to improving supply and less competition.

Read More
NFL Star Mike Pouncey Lists $6.95M Fort Lauderdale Home with Private Waterfront Football Field

Set on an oversized double lot just minutes from Las Olas, the three-story home includes five ensuite bedrooms and six and a half bathrooms.

Read More
Lynd Secures $132.5 Million in Refinancing for The Villas at Tuttle Royale

The bridge loan provided by MF1 Capital will retire a construction loan for the property,

Read More
Real Estate Authority Joins Forces with Charles Rutenberg Realty Fort Lauderdale in Strategic Merger

Strategic merger adds new talent and resources to expand United’s market share in South Florida

Read More