What Happens When a Board Member Refuses a Give-or-Get Policy?

By Gerry Czarnecki

Fundraising calls for what often is described as the “give-or-get” policy. The majority of boards have such a policy in place, so what should a board do when a member essentially refuses to commit to it?

There’s no clear answer, as every board runs differently, but if the board has such a policy commitment, or wants to have such a commitment, then several things will emerge as required actions:

The board must declare fundraising a critical role of board membership and that most funders expect 100 percent participation by the board of directors. This 100 percent should be clearly understood and consistent with the net worth and income capacity of the individual. Frequently, when highly valued board members do not have the financial resources to make as large a contribution as others, they can’t contribute.

The board must decide that each board member has a give-or-get goal. This must be a board decision. It cannot be simply decided by the chair, president or even a committee of the board. It is all about buy-in from the board members.

The board must also decide that each board member is expected to personally give some amount of money. The board must pass a formal resolution, stating that all board members are expected to either give, or help in getting and/or funding for the organization, and that they will establish an aspirational goal to “give or get” a specific amount of money each year.

Each new board member must be fully informed that the board has committed to the give-or-get process, and that they will be expected to commit and comply, in order to be a viable board prospect.

Each board member should be required to sign a formal aspiration agreement for the goal and understand that personal giving is imperative.

Then, and only then, should the board be prepared to act in the face of a board member’s refusal to participate in the give-or-get program.

Obviously, informal or formal communications would need to state to an offender that he or she is in violation of board policy and that the only remedy is to contribute or facilitate a raise.

In the absence of compliance, to be fair to the rest of the directors, and to reinforce the critical nature of this part of the role, any director ultimately refusing to participate should either be asked to step down or should not be re-nominated at the next board member election.

In short, fundraising is an essential priority for virtually all nonprofits.The give-or-get goals are crucial. Any member not participating simply does not have the level of commitment to the organization that every board has a right to expect from its members. This is not harsh; it is practicing fairness.

Gerry Czarnecki is founder and chairman of the nonprofit National Leadership Institute (nationalleadershipinstitute.org), which helps boards of nonprofit organizations become strategic assets to the leadership team. His extensive background as a C-suite executive and CEO is coupled with current board leadership of corporate and nonprofit organizations. He is also chairman and CEO of the Deltennium Group. Contact him at 561.293.3726 or gmc@deltennium.com.

You May Also Like
Real Estate Company Secures Four Law Firm Office Leases in Boca Raton

The offices are at the Eighteen Zero One and Boca Corporate Plaza buildings.

Read More
Office Leases in Boca Raton
Get Ready to Haggle If You Want a Buyer’s Real Estate Agent

Lawsuits are claiming that the commissions paid to the buyer’s agents shouldn’t be dictated by the Multiple Listing Service.

Read More
Real Estate Agent
Hard Work Pays Off

A food empire is growing in South Florida because of Mike Linder’s focus on food and service and a twist on locations.

Read More
One of the World’s Richest Women Makes a Major Gift

West Palm Beach is poised to establish a core of top-rated medical centers.

Read More
Other Posts
An Unknown Side of Cancun: Enjoy a Luxurious Stay at the JW Marriott Resort and Spa and Bring Your Taste for Adventure

Treat yourself to luxury, relaxation and unforgettable experiences at this fantastic resort.

Read More
Steiger Facial Plastic Surgery Offers Pamper Mom Facial Special

The offering is available through May 31.

Read More
NAIOP South Florida Appoints Officers, Executive Board and Board of Directors for 2022

NAIOP South Florida, a Commercial Real Estate Development Association offering advocacy, education and business opportunities to its members, has announced the following officers for the 2022 Board of Directors: President:

Read More
Pride Week Festival Begins With Tribute to Pulse Nightclub Survivor

Miami Beach Pride’s week-long festivities will commence with a special tribute to the LGBTQ+ community honoring the victims of the tragic shooting at Pulse Nightclub in Orlando. A ceremonial “flip

Read More